Buying Vintage Equestrian: How to Tell Decoration from Equipment

A hundred-year-old brass whip rack and a hundred-year-old girth are both sold as vintage. The girth may look beautiful and still be unsafe. Both are listed under the same word, and the buyer is left to tell them apart.

One question separates them. Ask it before you look at price, maker or condition.

The Safety Question

Does the piece carry weight or take strain? Does it hold a rider, control a horse, or protect a body in a fall?

If not, age is an advantage. It has already lasted a century. Its age does nothing to stop it hanging on a wall or holding a blanket.

If it does, age is a risk. It is also a risk you usually cannot see.

What Age Does to Leather

Leather does not only wear out with use. It also breaks down slowly on its own, even if no one rides in it. Research on old leather describes two causes working at once. Heat, light, dry air and pollution weaken the fibers. Moisture breaks them down further.

This damage cannot be judged by eye. A 2019 study in the journal Heritage Science developed laboratory tests for it because it does not show on the surface.

That is the heart of it. An old strap can look soft, sound and well kept and still be weak inside. A good-looking surface is not proof of strength. A photograph is not an inspection.

Never Buy Secondhand

Two items are off the list at any age.

Helmets. Horse & Hound's advice on secondhand equipment is clear: never buy a secondhand riding hat. A single fall can damage the inside of a helmet with no visible sign, and no seller can prove a helmet's history. A vintage helmet also predates today's standards. The United States Equestrian Federation and the United States Pony Club each publish their own list of accepted helmet standards. ASTM with the SEI mark is one, but it is not the only one. A helmet without a current accepted mark cannot be used in competition, however well it has been kept.

Body protectors. The British Equestrian Trade Association recommends replacing a body protector at least every three to five years, depending on use and care, because the foam may absorb impact less well over time. It also advises against secondhand body protectors, or any with an unknown history, because damage can be hidden.

Buy Only After Inspection

Some used equipment is worth owning, as long as it is checked rather than trusted.

Have a professional saddler check a secondhand saddle before you buy it. The frame inside a saddle, called the tree, can break with no sign on the outside.

Girths, stirrup leathers and bridles should be examined in person. Pull hard on the stitching, especially on stirrup leathers, which carry much of the rider's weight. Look closely wherever the leather bends through a buckle. On a bridle, check the hook fastenings and make sure the leather around them has not stretched loose.

None of these checks can be done from a photo. That is a limit of buying vintage equipment online.

Heritage Makers Still at Work

There is a third option: new pieces with the qualities age stands for. Good materials, careful work, and a maker with long experience.

Some of those houses are still at work. New leather has no hidden history. It can be checked before it is used.

Passier. Founded in Hanover, Germany, on 17 September 1867 by Georg Christian Passier, an army saddler. Passier states that it still makes bridles and saddles in Germany. Five of its bridles are in The Bridle Edit: the Juno at $280, the Blu Spirit at $345, the Marcus Ehning II at $535, the Atlas at $600 and the Harmony at $890.

Herm Sprenger. Founded in Iserlohn, Germany, in 1872 by Hermann Sprenger, as a factory making fittings for horses and harness. Its KK Ultra and Dynamic RS bits in The Bit Edit range from $235.90 to $290.90. Herm Sprenger states that Sensogan, the metal in its KK Ultra bits, is its own blend and not a coating.

Sedgwick. J. & E. Sedgwick & Co. is a traditional English tannery in Walsall that makes leather for bridles. Sedgwick states that its bridle leather is tanned the traditional way, with tree bark. Huntley Equestrian states that it buys its leather from Sedgwick. Sedgwick leather appears in our collections in two pieces: the Huntley Equestrian fancy stitched padded bridle with reins in The Bridle Edit, from $419.99, and Sedgwick's own leather care, from $12.99.

Choosing between a hundred-year-old bridle with an unknown past and a new Passier is not a choice between old and new. A new bridle comes with a known history. An old one does not.

Lower Risk Pieces

Anything that does not carry weight or take strain is lower risk. Sporting prints, paintings and old photographs. Trophies, plates and engraved cups. Brass and iron stable fittings. Whip racks and hunting horns. Boot jacks and boot pulls. Blanket bars, saddle racks and hooks. Horn and carved wooden pieces, and folding travel furniture. Trunks. Stable signs, ribbons and hunt buttons.

None of it carries a rider or controls a horse. Age costs it nothing.

Where to Look

These are sources for riders.

To see a wide range quickly, try the online design marketplaces. Chairish lists equestrian and sporting decor at many price points. 1stDibs works the same way at higher prices, and includes nineteenth century English pieces such as London-made whip racks.

Two specialist dealers focus on equestrian pieces. Wellington and Co. in Charlotte deals only in equestrian and fox hunting antiques. It states that everything it sells is antique and original, with no reproductions, and it works by appointment. Anderson Jones Equestrian lists smaller pieces: antique and vintage equestrian jewelry, stick pins, cuff links, flasks and barware, along with art and collectibles.

For sporting art, Cross Gate Gallery in Lexington co-hosts The Sporting Art Auction at Keeneland, which has run for more than a decade and brought in $2.8 million at its 2023 sale. The auction catalogs show prices and examples.

To shop in person, visit the antiques shops in and around Middleburg, Virginia. The town sits in the middle of hunt country. Holding a piece answers questions a listing cannot.

Reading a Listing

For decorative pieces, buying online is entirely reasonable. Look for four things in a listing.

Measurements given in numbers, not described with adjectives. A clear history of the piece, including what is known and what is guessed. Close-up photos of the places that fail first: joints, feet, hinges, frames and anywhere two materials meet. A return policy written in plain language.

A seller who gives all four expects the piece to pass inspection. A seller who gives none has told you something too.

One last step for anything used on another horse: disinfect it before use. Shared equipment can spread disease between horses, and cleaning it is a small job compared with the risk.

Vintage rewards a rider who knows which question to ask. Decoration is a matter of taste, and taste improves with age. Equipment is a matter of safety, and safety does not care how handsome the leather is.

Tack and stable storage are in The Refined Tack Room. Helmet certification is explained in Helmet Safety and Replacement.

Sources

Horse & Hound, how to buy secondhand equestrian kit and not get caught out. British Equestrian Trade Association, body protector guidance and the BETA 2018 standard. Heritage Science, study of leather breakdown, 2019. Passier and Herm Sprenger company histories, each from the maker's own published record. Keeneland, Sporting Art Auction results, 2023. Dealer descriptions taken from each dealer's own published material.

Decide once, rather than wonder each season.

Download your complimentary Tack Room Reset here.